The UK hydrogen economy is struggling to move beyond feasibility studies and into commercial deployment, with uncertain government policy, insufficient infrastructure and a lack of committed customers holding back investment, according to Atlas Copco.

Speaking to The Energyst, Chris Hyde, Business Line Manager for Air and Gas Applications at Atlas Copco Compressors UK, said the industry had moved beyond its initial excitement but was finding the transition to commercially viable projects increasingly challenging.

“I think we’ve definitely gone past the excitement of it,” said Hyde, explaining that the volume of speculative enquiries had fallen significantly.

While privately funded pilot projects are beginning to demonstrate progress, larger developments remain constrained by financing difficulties and uncertainty over long-term demand.

Hyde highlighted what he described as “FEED (Front-End Engineering Design) fatigue”, with developers repeatedly undertaking front-end engineering design studies without progressing to construction.

“Over the last probably 12 to 18 months, we’ve seen a cycle of FEED study after FEED study after FEED study,” he said.

The situation has prompted Atlas Copco to become more selective about which projects receive its engineering resources.

Industrial demand holds the key

Despite these challenges, Hyde believes hydrogen has an important role in decarbonising energy-intensive industries, particularly steel, cement, ceramics and other hard-to-abate sectors.

However, he cautioned against positioning hydrogen as a universal alternative to electrification.

“Green hydrogen will not replace everything. That’s not the goal. The goal is for it to be part of a much wider ecosystem.”

Smaller hydrogen applications, including remote power generation and specialist industrial uses, are already demonstrating potential. But Hyde argued that demand from major industrial consumers will ultimately determine whether the sector achieves meaningful scale.

Long-term offtake agreements are particularly important because they provide the commercial certainty needed to attract private investment.

“When it comes to private investment, that is honestly the linchpin,” he said.

Without commitments from major energy users, hydrogen producers face difficulties securing the financing necessary to develop larger facilities.

Government strategy under scrutiny

Hyde was critical of the UK’s approach to hydrogen policy, arguing that changing political priorities have undermined investor confidence.

“I think the lack of a long-term strategic plan is what I would say is the reason for it struggling more so in the UK,” he said.

He contrasted the UK with Germany and Denmark, where investment in hydrogen pipeline infrastructure is helping to establish the foundations for future industrial demand.

Although the UK remains an important location for hydrogen innovation and pilot projects, Hyde warned that companies could increasingly seek investment elsewhere if domestic conditions fail to improve.

High electricity prices present another obstacle, particularly for green hydrogen produced through electrolysis.

Hyde argued that hydrogen must be considered alongside other energy technologies, with commercial viability taking priority over an exclusive focus on individual production methods.

Compression and infrastructure challenges

Atlas Copco sees opportunities in the equipment required to compress, store and transport hydrogen, although Hyde acknowledged that the hydrogen mobility market has developed more slowly than anticipated.

The company’s H2Y hydraulic hydrogen booster can compress gas to pressures approaching 1,000 bar, supporting applications including high-pressure storage and distribution.

Its H2P technology provides a lower-pressure alternative, with potential applications linked to the development of hydrogen infrastructure.

Hyde stressed that the wider infrastructure requirements are sometimes underestimated.

“If you produce the hydrogen itself and can’t store it, distribute it, then hydrogen is not useful either.”

He also highlighted the importance of safety and operational experience, particularly for industrial businesses unfamiliar with handling hydrogen.

A critical period for investment

Looking towards 2030, Hyde remains optimistic that hydrogen could become a more significant part of Atlas Copco’s business, but believes the next few years will be decisive.

He wants to see faster investment decisions, clearer government direction and major industrial customers committing to long-term hydrogen purchases.

The UK has strengths in engineering and early-stage project development, he explained, but these do not automatically translate into domestic investment or deployment.

Hyde also acknowledged the risk that hydrogen has been oversold in applications where other decarbonisation technologies could prove more practical.

Ultimately, he believes the industry’s future depends on converting technical capability into genuine commercial demand.

“If they don’t do it, I don’t think hydrogen will be successful,” he said, referring to the major energy-intensive industries whose participation will be essential to establishing a viable hydrogen economy.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here