Report: Ditch coal earlier, forget small nuclear and mandate energy storage and DSR targets


ferrybridgeGovernment should phase out coal by 2023 to better incentivise new gas plant and mandate 10GW of energy storage and demand-side response by 2030, according to a report by a green-leaning Conservative think tank.

Bright Blue’s Keeping the Lights On report outlines scenarios for security of supply and decarbonisation. While engineers have warned that the UK faces a massive generation gap when coal closes in 2025, the think tank suggests otherwise. It believes renewable power can fill the generation gap left in the late 2020s by a potential failure to construct Hinkley Point C and recommends government makes this approach its plan B, given that renewable costs continue to fall. It places little faith in small modular nuclear reactors being available by 2030, if at all.

Bright Blue says its ‘low stress’ scenario is the most secure and least polluting approach, which also places the lowest cost on energy bills.

Under that scenario, only 8GW of new gas beyond what is already committed would be needed by 2030, according to the report. Government should encourage renewables, interconnection and energy efficiency, it recommends. Government should also develop targets for 4-5GW of DSR and 5-6GW of storage by 2030, states the report, as well as plans for small reciprocating gas engines, which it says can balance out intermittent renewables more cost effectively than large scale plants.

Meanwhile policymakers should implement an emissions performance standard (EPS) to bring coal off the system and provide a clearer signal for new gas developers. Without that signal, little new gas will be built until coal is phased out at the end of 2025, according to the think tank.

Under all its scenarios, UK lights will stay on and no new gas is required over the next four years, according to Bright Blue, which said it would shortly publish recommendations for energy efficiency policy via a separate report.

Download the full report here.

Related stories:

Free demand-side response conference

Demand-side response: Give us your views

UK facing massive power shortfalls when coal stations close, warn engineers

National Grid signs 20MW demand-side response contract with battery storage operator

Decc says energy storage ‘a top priority’

Capacity market rule changes create opportunity for turn-down DSR

Major changes to capacity market and distributed generation charging regime proposed

Energy brokers and TPIs warn early capacity market could add 5% to power bills

New aggregator targets small firms with UPS for demand-response push

Government backs Adonis’ smartgrid plan, pledges £50m+ for storage and demand response

UK must prioritise smartgrid, says National Infrastructure Commission

National Grid says impact of solar requires greater system flexibility

Decc commits to annual plan and to consult on energy storage

National Grid to tender for 200MW of superfast demand response next month

Major changes to capacity market proposed


National Grid must simplify demand response to scale UK market

40% of firms say they could shift energy use as National Grid asks them to turn up

Dong enters demand-side response market with wind power balancing service

National Grid buys 475MW of demand response to cover winter

2016: the year half hourly settlement will hit your power bill

Government to consult on demand response in spring

Energy Technologies Institute: Let private firms run smartgrid trials

Grid buys 3.6GW of back up power to prevent blackouts

Flexitricity warns demand response cannot be rushed as winter looms

National Infrastructure Commission to focus on energy storage and demand response

Is Triad past its peak?

Tempus: A five year old can see capacity market is anticompetitive

National Grid plots superfast grid balancing service

Many major energy users can’t be flexible, says manufacturing chief

National Grid moots demand side response rule changes as winter power margins tighten

Keep calm and scale demand response, says Scots energy inquiry

National Grid flags demand response changes, urges suppliers and TPIs to deliver

National Grid must simplify demand response to bring in UK businesses

Ofgem boss flags rule changes to speed demand response

National Grid launches major demand side push

Demand response: Suppliers and aggregators ignoring 80% of UK firms

UK firms with CHP plant could be paid to stop exporting power

National Grid: No margin? No sweat

Demand response provider teams with Honeywell, touts for new business

Free report: Directors’ energy outlook report 2016

Free report: How to finance energy efficiency

Click here to see if you qualify for a free subscription to the print edition of The Energyst, or to renew.

Follow us at @EnergystMedia. For regular bulletins, sign up for the free newsletter.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here